A Multi-Crystal Method for Extracting Obscured Signal from Crystallographic Electron Density
Pearce NM., Bradley AR., Collins P., Krojer T., Nowak RP., Talon R., Marsden BD., Kelm S., Shi J., Deane CM., von Delft F.
AbstractMacromolecular crystallography is relied on to reveal subtle atomic difference between samples (e.g. ligand binding); yet their detection and modelling is subjective and ambiguous density is experimentally common, since molecular states of interest are generally only fractionally present. The existing approach relies on careful modelling for maximally accurate maps to make contributions of the minor fractions visible (1); in practice, this is time-consuming and non-objective (2–4). Instead, our PanDDA method automatically reveals clear electron density for only the changed state, even from poor models and inaccurate maps, by subtracting a proportion of the confounding ground state, accurately estimated by averaging many ground state crystals. Changed states are objectively identifiable from statistical distributions of density values; arbitrarily large searches are thus automatable. The method is completely general, implying new best practice for all changed-state studies. Finally, we demonstrate the incompleteness of current atomic models, and the need for new multi-crystal deconvolution paradigms.One Sentence SummaryNormally uninterpretable map regions are reliably modelled by deconvoluting superposed crystal states, even with poor starting models.